Best automotive replacement oil pump gaskets, ranked

Product Category Search

AI-generated summary · updated August 10, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

1. 

   1 Best overall Fel-Pro

   Fel-Pro OS 34340 R Oil Pan Gasket

   ★★★★★4.6/5 $33.53

   High-quality rubberized material with steel core for excellent sealing; fits many GM engines.

   • Durable material
   • Easy to install
   • Reliable seal

   • May be overpriced for some

   View on Amazon
2. 

   2 Best value MAHLE

   Mahle Original 31707 Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.5/5 $6.93 Only 15 left

   Precision-molded gasket for oil pump assembly; good sealing and durability.

   • Good fit
   • Affordable
   • Quality construction

   View on Amazon
3. 

   3 Best budget pick Victor Reinz

   Victor Reinz 71-52762-00 Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.4/5 $20.84 Only 5 left

   Economical yet reliable gasket for oil pump applications; suitable for many domestic engines.

   • Low cost
   • Decent quality
   • Widely available

   • May not fit all models

   View on Amazon
4. 4 Best set

   Durabond 250-4100 Oil Pump Gasket Set

   ★★★★☆4.3/5 $15-$20

   Includes multiple gaskets for oil pump and related components; comprehensive solution.

   • Complete set
   • Good value
   • Easy installation

   • Some pieces may be unnecessary

   View on Amazon
5. 

   5 Budget option atp automotive

   ATP Automotive A-2001 Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.2/5 $10.23 Only 10 left

   Simple paper gasket for basic oil pump sealing; inexpensive and functional.

   • Very cheap
   • Simple design
   • Works as intended

   • Less durable than rubber
   • Not for high-performance

   View on Amazon
6. 

   6 Premium choice Fel-Pro

   Fel-Pro OS 34341 R Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.5/5 $52.98

   Premium rubber elastomer gasket with steel core; excellent for heavy-duty use.

   • High durability
   • Excellent seal
   • Long-lasting

   • Higher price

   View on Amazon
7. 

   7 OE replacement Melling

   Melling M-329 Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.4/5 $5.87

   Direct replacement for many Melling oil pumps; ensures proper fit and function.

   • Exact fit
   • Quality material
   • Trusted brand

   • Limited compatibility

   View on Amazon
8. 

   8 Reliable seal Melling

   SKF 18588 Oil Pump Gasket

   ★★★★☆4.3/5 $5.87

   SKF's rubber-coated gasket provides excellent sealing against leaks.

   • Non-stick coating
   • Good seal
   • Durable

   • May need sealant

   View on Amazon

You Might Also Like

• automotive replacement air conditioning shaft nuts
• automotive replacement carburetor accelerator pumps
• automotive replacement fuel pump bowl gaskets
• automotive replacement axle flange gaskets
• automotive replacement air conditioning compressor bearings
• automotive replacement engine timing part covers
• automotive replacement switch to starter battery cables
• automotive replacement windshield wiper nozzles
• automotive replacement crankshaft seals
• automotive replacement manual bearing retainer seals
• automotive replacement clutch slave cylinders
• automotive replacement windshield wiper de-icing strips
• automotive replacement air conditioning valves
• automotive replacement belt tensioners
• automotive replacement flexplates