Product Category Search

Top rated ice cream and soft serve mixes

AI-generated summary · updated July 27, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

  1. Best overall

    Tillamook Mudslide Ice Cream

    4.7/5 $5-$7

    Rich chocolate and coffee ice cream with fudge & cookie pieces; highly rated for flavor and quality.

    • Creamy texture
    • Generous mix-ins
    • Great value
    • Contains dairy
  2. Best low-calorie

    Halo Top Chocolate Ice Cream

    4.5/5 $5-$6

    Low-calorie, high-protein chocolate ice cream; popular for guilt-free indulgence.

    • Low calorie per pint
    • Good protein content
    • Satisfies chocolate cravings
    • Slightly icy texture
    • Less creamy than full-fat
  3. Best mix-ins

    Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream

    4.6/5 $5-$7

    Chocolate and vanilla ice creams with fudge brownie & cookie dough; beloved for its variety.

    • Packed with mix-ins
    • Rich flavor
    • Fun texture
    • High in sugar and calories
    • Expensive for pint
  4. Best budget

    Edy's/Dreyer's Slow Churned Vanilla Ice Cream

    4.5/5 $4-$6

    Classic vanilla with creamy texture; affordable and versatile for toppings.

    • Affordable price
    • Smooth and creamy
    • Classic flavor
    • Simple flavor profile
    • Contains artificial stabilizers
  5. Best gelato

    Talenti Sea Salt Caramel Gelato

    4.7/5 $5-$7

    Dense, premium gelato with sweet-salty caramel; praised for authentic Italian taste.

    • Rich and dense
    • High-quality ingredients
    • Excellent caramel flavor
    • Small portion size
    • High calorie density
  6. Best indulgent treat

    Magnum Classic Ice Cream Bars

    4.6/5 $5-$8

    Vanilla ice cream dipped in thick Belgian chocolate; top-rated for richness.

    • Thick chocolate coating
    • Premium taste
    • Convenient bar format
    • Melts quickly
    • High in sugar and fat

Buying advice

Consider your priority: for maximum flavor and mix-ins, Ben & Jerry's or Tillamook are top; for lower calories, Halo Top; for affordable classics, Edy's/Dreyer's. Check ingredients if you have dietary restrictions (dairy, gluten). Prices may vary by location and size.

Related Queries