Product Category Search
Top rated mayonnaise
-
Best overall HELLMANN'SHellmann's Real Mayonnaise, 30 oz
Classic, creamy mayonnaise with a balanced flavor; widely available and consistently rated among top brands.
- Rich, creamy texture
- Well-loved classic taste
- Versatile for many recipes
- Contains eggs and soybean oil
-
Best for tangy flavor DUKE'SDuke's Mayonnaise, 32 oz
Twangier than competitors due to extra vinegar and no sugar; a cult favorite in the South.
- Tangy, distinct taste
- No added sugar
- Creamy and thick consistency
- Regional availability issues
-
Best value KraftKraft Real Mayonnaise, 30 oz
Affordable, smooth mayonnaise that delivers good flavor; often on sale and widely available.
- Great price point
- Mild, crowd-pleasing taste
- Smooth texture
- Less distinctive than premium brands
-
Best West Coast choice Best FoodsBest Foods Real Mayonnaise, 30 oz
Identical recipe to Hellmann's east of Rockies; creamy, quality mayo with a loyal following.
- Same high quality as Hellmann's
- Creamy and rich
- Widely available in West
- Same formula as Hellmann's
-
Best premium option Sir Kensington'sSir Kensington's Classic Mayonnaise, 16 oz
Made with cage-free eggs, non-GMO ingredients; clean label and rich, smooth flavor.
- All-natural ingredients
- Non-GMO verified
- Smooth, premium taste
- Higher price point
- Smaller jar size
-
Best organic choiceSpectrum Organic Mayonnaise, 16 oz
USDA organic, non-GMO mayonnaise with a clean taste made from organic oils and eggs.
- USDA certified organic
- Non-GMO
- Clean, simple ingredients
- Slightly higher cost
- Some find flavor bland
-
Best budget organic Trader Joe'sTrader Joe's Organic Mayonnaise, 16 oz
Trader Joe's organic version offers great value with good taste and organic certification.
- Organic at low price
- Good flavor
- Creamy texture
- Only available at Trader Joe's
-
Best for paleo/keto Primal KitchenPrimal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayonnaise, 12 oz
Made with avocado oil and no seed oils; paleo and keto-friendly with a light, creamy texture.
- Avocado oil base
- No refined seed oils
- Whole30 and paleo compliant
- Expensive per ounce
- Thinner consistency than traditional mayo