The best mystery anthologies books you can buy

Product Category Search

The best mystery anthologies books you can buy

AI-generated summary · updated September 4, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

1 Curated collection Mariner
The Best American Mystery Stories 2023

4.4/5 $11.79

Annual anthology featuring top mystery short stories selected by a guest editor, offering diverse voices and styles.
- High-quality curation
- Diverse authors
- Great for discovering new writers
- Some stories may not appeal to all
View on Amazon
2 Cozy mystery fans CREATESPACE
Murder in the Mystery Room: An Anthology

4.3/5 $10.49

Collection of cozy mystery tales set in a bookshop, perfect for light-hearted sleuthing.
- Engaging setting
- Light and fun
- Perfect for mystery lovers
- Not for hardboiled fans
View on Amazon
3 Gift for mystery lovers
Mystery Writers of America Presents: The Mystery Box

4.2/5 $11.99

Anthology from MWA with stories by acclaimed authors, each revolving around a mysterious box.
- Renowned authors
- Creative theme
- Great variety
- Some stories feel short
View on Amazon
4 Classic mystery aficionados Penguin
The Penguin Book of Murder Mysteries

4.5/5 $11.51 Only 3 left

Timeless collection of classic murder mystery stories from the golden age to modern times.
- Classic tales
- Well-edited
- Historical value
- May lack contemporary stories
View on Amazon
5 Modern mystery readers
Mystery Tribune: Best Mystery Stories 2024

4.1/5 $12-$18

Curated selection of contemporary mystery stories from emerging and established authors.
- Current and relevant
- Fresh voices
- Good pacing
- Less name recognition
View on Amazon
6 Best overall
Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine's Anthology: 80th Anniversary

4.6/5 $14-$20

Celebrates 80 years of the iconic magazine, featuring award-winning stories and fan favorites.
- Award-winning content
- Historic significance
- High quality
- None notable
View on Amazon
7 Suspense lovers Pegasus Books
Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine Presents: Fifty Years of Crime

4.3/5 $19.99

Collection from the legendary magazine featuring suspenseful and twisty mystery stories.
- Suspenseful
- Iconic brand
- Twist endings
- Some dated writing
View on Amazon
8 Puzzle enthusiasts Vintage Crime/Black Lizard
The Big Book of Locked-Room Mysteries

4.4/5 $17.37 Only 1 left

Massive anthology of impossible crime stories, perfect for fans of clever puzzles.
- Large collection
- Brain-teasing plots
- Excellent for fans
- Might be too long
View on Amazon

Buying advice

When choosing a mystery anthology, consider whether you prefer classic or contemporary stories, and look for collections that align with your favorite subgenre (cozy, hardboiled, puzzle). Check the table of contents for well-known authors. Anthologies by established magazines or organizations often have higher curation quality.

Product Category Search

The best mystery anthologies books you can buy

Buying advice

You Might Also Like