Product Category Search

Top rated pumpernickel sandwich bread

AI-generated summary · updated July 28, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

  1. Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread
    Best traditional Mestemacher

    Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread

    4.5/5 $17.99

    Authentic German-style dense, dark pumpernickel with whole grains, high fiber, and no added sugar.

    • High fiber
    • No added sugar
    • Authentic taste
    • Dense texture may not suit all
    • Pricey
  2. Arnold Premium Pumpernickel Bread
    Best value Arnold

    Arnold Premium Pumpernickel Bread

    4.3/5 $5.09 Only 13 left

    Affordable and soft pumpernickel with a mild flavor, suitable for sandwiches and toasting.

    • Low price
    • Soft texture
    • Mild flavor
    • Less fiber than traditional
    • Contains preservatives
  3. Bread Alone Organic Pumpernickel Bread
    Best organic Mestemacher

    Bread Alone Organic Pumpernickel Bread

    4.2/5 $17.99

    Organic, stone-ground pumpernickel with a hearty taste and chewy crust, free from artificial ingredients.

    • Organic ingredients
    • Chewy crust
    • No artificial additives
    • Shorter shelf life
    • Higher price
  4. Rubschlager Cocktail Pumpernickel Bread
    Best for appetizers S. Rosen's

    Rubschlager Cocktail Pumpernickel Bread

    4.6/5 $46.99 Only 17 left

    Mini square slices perfect for party appetizers and canapés, with a dense, dark rye-pumpernickel flavor.

    • Great for parties
    • Dense texture
    • Unique size
    • Small slices
    • Limited use for full sandwiches
  5. Bread SRSLY Gluten Free Pumpernickel Bread
    Best gluten-free Brot & Crust

    Bread SRSLY Gluten Free Pumpernickel Bread

    4.3/5 $17.99

    Gluten-free pumpernickel made with sorghum and teff, offering a moist crumb and authentic flavor for those with dietary restrictions.

    • Gluten-free
    • Moist texture
    • Good flavor
    • Expensive
    • Small loaf
  6. Silver Hills Sprouted Power Pumpernickel Bread
    Best sprouted grain Silver Hills Bakery

    Silver Hills Sprouted Power Pumpernickel Bread

    4.4/5 $4.56 Only 5 left

    Sprouted grain pumpernickel with no flour, no preservatives, and a dense, nutty flavor packed with protein.

    • High protein
    • No flour
    • No preservatives
    • Dense and heavy
    • Pricey
  7. Pepperidge Farm Pumpernickel Swirl Bread
    Best overall Pepperidge Farm

    Pepperidge Farm Pumpernickel Swirl Bread

    4.4/5 $4-$6 Currently unavailable

    A classic, widely available pumpernickel swirl bread with a balanced sweet and tangy flavor, soft texture, and good value.

    • Consistent quality
    • Widely available
    • Good flavor
    • Contains high fructose corn syrup
  8. 365 by Whole Foods Market Pumpernickel Bread
    Best budget pick 365 by Whole Foods Market

    365 by Whole Foods Market Pumpernickel Bread

    4.1/5 $3-$5 Currently unavailable

    Store brand option with decent flavor and soft texture at a low price, widely available at Whole Foods.

    • Very affordable
    • Soft texture
    • Good for sandwiches
    • Less robust flavor
    • Contains additives

Buying advice

When selecting pumpernickel bread, consider whether you prefer traditional dense German-style or softer American-style. Check ingredients for added sugars, preservatives, or gluten if you have dietary restrictions. For the best value, Arnold offers a solid option; for authentic flavor, try Mestemacher.

Related Queries