Top rated teen and young adult fantasy and supernatural mysteries and thrillers books

Product Category Search

Top rated teen and young adult fantasy and supernatural mysteries and thrillers books

AI-generated summary · updated July 27, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

1 Best overall LITTLE, BROWN
The Cruel Prince (The Folk of the Air)

4.5/5 $7.38

A dark and captivating fantasy with political intrigue and complex characters, highly praised for its twisty plot.
- Rich world-building
- Unpredictable twists
- Strong character development
- Slow start for some readers
View on Amazon
2 Best mystery thriller Delacorte Press
One of Us Is Lying

4.4/5 $7.07

A gripping YA mystery thriller with multiple perspectives, often compared to 'The Breakfast Club' meets murder.
- Engaging plot
- Well-developed characters
- Fast-paced
- Predictable for some
View on Amazon
3 Best supernatural thriller Storytide
Shatter Me

4.3/5 $8.99

A dystopian supernatural thriller with a unique writing style and a strong romance element, popular among teens.
- Creative premise
- Emotional depth
- Addictive writing
- Overly dramatic at times
View on Amazon
4 Best rated Ember
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

4.6/5 $6.59

A compelling YA murder mystery with a smart protagonist and a well-constructed case, highly acclaimed.
- Intelligent plot
- Engaging format
- Satisfying conclusion
- Some predictable elements
View on Amazon
5 Best puzzle mystery LITTLE, BROWN
The Inheritance Games

4.4/5 $5.92

A thrilling YA mystery full of puzzles, riddles, and a rich family legacy, perfect for fans of escape rooms.
- Clever puzzles
- Fast-paced
- Strong heroine
- Complex family tree
View on Amazon
6 Best emotional twist Ember
We Were Liars

4.1/5 $6.39

A haunting YA contemporary mystery with a shocking twist, known for its lyrical prose and emotional impact.
- Beautiful writing
- Unforgettable twist
- Emotional resonance
- Slow middle section
View on Amazon
7 Best fantasy heist Square Fish
Six of Crows

4.6/5 $17.48

A high-stakes fantasy heist with a diverse cast and intricate world-building, extremely popular among teens.
- Excellent world-building
- Complex characters
- Thrilling action
- Dense start
View on Amazon
8 Best dark fantasy Flatiron Books
The Hazel Wood

3.9/5 $6.17

A dark and eerie supernatural mystery blending fairy tales with reality, perfect for fans of twisted stories.
- Unique concept
- Atmospheric writing
- Creepy fairy tales
- Confusing plot at times
- Unsatisfying ending
View on Amazon

Buying advice

Consider what element you enjoy most - mystery, fantasy, or supernatural - and choose a book that emphasizes that. Check the reading level and age recommendations to ensure it's appropriate for the teen reader. Look for series openers if binge-reading is desired.

Product Category Search

Top rated teen and young adult fantasy and supernatural mysteries and thrillers books

Buying advice

Related Queries