Top rated buttermilks

Product Category Search

AI-generated summary · updated July 27, 2026 · verify details before purchase.

1. 1 Best overall

   Kate's ButterMilk, 32 oz

   ★★★★★4.7/5 $4-$6

   Cultured whole buttermilk with rich, creamy texture and tangy flavor, ideal for baking and drinking.

   • Creamy texture
   • Great for baking
   • No artificial additives

   • Limited availability

   View on Amazon manufacturer site
2. 2 Best value

   Lifeway Lowfat Buttermilk, 32 oz

   ★★★★☆4.5/5 $3-$5

   Lowfat cultured buttermilk with probiotics, providing good value and digestive benefits.

   • Probiotic rich
   • Low fat
   • Affordable

   • Thinner consistency

   View on Amazon manufacturer site
3. 3 Best organic

   Organic Valley Cultured Buttermilk, 32 oz

   ★★★★★4.6/5 $5-$7

   USDA organic cultured buttermilk from pasture-raised cows, rich and tangy.

   • Certified organic
   • Pasture-raised cows
   • Rich flavor

   • Higher price

   View on Amazon manufacturer site
4. 4 Best budget

   Borden Buttermilk, 32 oz

   ★★★★☆4.4/5 $3-$5

   Classic cultured buttermilk with smooth taste, widely available at low price.

   • Very affordable
   • Widely available
   • Smooth taste

   • May contain gums

   View on Amazon manufacturer site
5. 5 Best premium

   Kalona Supernatural Organic Buttermilk, 32 oz

   ★★★★★4.8/5 $6-$8

   Organic, non-homogenized, vat-pasteurized buttermilk from grass-fed cows; exceptionally rich.

   • Grass-fed cows
   • Non-homogenized
   • Superior creaminess

   • Pricey
   • Short shelf life

   View on Amazon manufacturer site
6. 6

   Daisy Sour Cream (Note: Not Buttermilk, Excluded)

   View on Amazon

Related Queries

• blue cheese
• processed cheese
• feta cheese
• sour creams
• parmesan cheese
• cheese curds
• egg whites
• vegetarian cheese
• provolone cheese
• flax milks
• whole eggs
• cottage cheeses
• gouda cheese
• whipped toppings
• yogurt drinks